What was meant to be a simple Valentine’s Day gesture quickly turns into a heated debate about expectations, mixed signals, and what a “romantic” gift really means when you’re not ready to commit. Is it just a thoughtful surprise… or does giving a V-Day gift send a message he wasn’t prepared to stand behind? We’re breaking down the present, the reactions, and the bigger question: was this sweet but misunderstood, or did Scotty completely blur the lines?