Quillette Cetera

Does Western civilisation actually exist — or is it just a modern political myth?

In this episode of the Quillette Cetera podcast, Zoe Booth speaks with classicist James Kierstead about the origins of the West, the “Greek miracle,” Christianity, monogamy, democracy, and the cultural foundations of modern civilisation.

They discuss:

Whether the West is real or an invented concept

Ancient Greece and the origins of egalitarianism

Why monogamy shaped Western civilisation

Protestant guilt and modern culture

Honour cultures vs dignity cultures

Christianity, Judaism, and Greco-Roman civilisation

Why the Industrial Revolution happened in the West

Whether Western civilisation can survive without Christianity

James Kierstead holds a BA in Classics from Oxford and a PhD in Political Science from Stanford University.

00:00 Intro to James Kierstead and his free speech issue at Victoria University03:35 Interview begins05:24 Taboos in Historical Discourse08:19 Chauvinism and Historical Narratives11:16 Cultural Identity and Modernization13:46 The Complexity of Modernization16:40 Cultural Traditions and Their Influence19:42 Monogamy and Western Values27:10 The Evolution of Monogamy and Polyamory29:48 Impact of Monogamy on Women32:52 The Roots of Western Egalitarianism34:36 The Greek Miracle: A Cultural Efflorescence40:04 Theories Behind Greek Egalitarianism45:38 Polygamy and Its Societal Implications48:40 Morality and Cultural Differences50:58 Japanese Culture and Honor53:35 The Influence of Ancient Greece55:51 Christianity and Its Roots58:25 The Nature of Religious Conversion01:00:16 Judeo-Christian Values and Greek Influence01:03:07 The Impact of the Levant on Global Culture01:06:42 Future of Western Civilization

#WesternCivilization #AncientGreece #Christianity #History #Civilization #Quillette #Philosophy #Politics #JamesKierstead
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

In this conversation, Zoe Booth and Shany Mor discuss the complex interplay between Australia's reputation in relation to Israel, the impact of anti-Israel activism, and the cultural and intellectual anxieties that contribute to anti-Semitism. They explore the role of guilt in Western society, the challenges of identity and belonging in multicultural contexts, and the evolution of political discourse. The discussion also touches on the dynamics of radicalization, the nature of prejudice, and the future of democracy, particularly in the context of Israeli society and global fertility rates.

Chapters

00:00 Australia's Protests and Israel's Perception

05:47 Understanding Anti-Israel Sentiment

07:58 The Role of Intellectualism in Anti-Semitism

10:27 Cultural Anxiety and Scapegoating

12:53 Oikophobia and Western Guilt

15:35 Moral Accounting and Identity Politics

18:04 The Impact of 9/11 on Western Discourse

20:27 Feminism and Cultural Symbols

23:01 The Transformation of Western Society

25:39 Radicalization and Immigrant Perspectives

28:14 The Role of Western Elites in Anti-Semitism

30:46 Media Narratives and Perceptions of Violence

30:54 Understanding Jewish Identity and Community Challenges

33:14 The Impact of Anti-Zionism on Academia

35:22 Cultural Myths and Their Influence on Society

36:59 Exploring Fertility Rates and Societal Values

42:08 Democracy in Crisis: The Referendum on Truth

47:56 The Legacy of the Post-War Order and Its Challenges

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

Shay Khatiri is one of the most clear-eyed analysts of Iran’s regime and its role in global geopolitics. Raised in the Islamic Republic before escaping to the U.S., he now serves as Vice President and Senior Fellow at the Yorktown Institute and writes The Russia–Iran File, a Substack dissecting the domestic and foreign policy strategies of both regimes. His work has appeared in The Wall Street Journal, National Review, The Bulwark, Providence, and Quillette.

In this episode, he joins Zoe to unpack the roots of Iran’s latest deadly protests, including the regime’s use of pellet guns and hospital raids to suppress dissent. He explains why so many Iranians are calling for foreign military intervention, what a post-regime Iran might look like, and why he believes a constitutional monarchy—led by Reza Pahlavi—offers the best hope for stability. They also discuss the role of the diaspora, the rise of underground Christianity, and why the West’s inaction may extinguish Iran’s last chance at revolution.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

In this conversation, Zoe Booth and Adam Louis-Klein delve into the complexities of antizionism, exploring its ideological roots, the language used to propagate it, and its normalisation in contemporary society. They discuss the formation of the Movement Against Antizionism (MAAZ) and the importance of recognising antizionism as a distinct form of bigotry. The dialogue also addresses the historical context of antizionism, its evolution in academia, and the psychological warfare embedded in its rhetoric. Throughout, practical strategies are offered for countering antizionist claims—emphasising the need for clarity, courage, and a comprehensive understanding of the issue.

Adam Louis-Klein is an anthropologist and PhD candidate at McGill University. His research focuses on Indigenous cosmologies in the Colombian Amazon and comparative forms of peoplehood. He is the founder of the Movement Against Antizionism (MAAZ), which challenges antizionist ideology as a distinct form of anti-Jewish hatred. His writing and advocacy explore the intersection of academic discourse, identity, and political propaganda.

Timestamps

00:00 Introduction to Adam Louis-Klein and MAAZ

04:00 Interview begins: The Birth of MAAZ and Antizionism

09:10 Language and the Inversion of Reality

11:28 The Evolution of Antizionism

14:08 The Role of Academia in Antizionism

16:55 The Historical Context of Antizionism

19:21 Modern Antizionism and Its Global Impact

21:43 Government Responses to Antizionism

24:33 Understanding Antizionism vs. Antisemitism

27:18 The Psychological Mechanisms Behind Antizionism

29:50 The Australian Context of Antizionism

31:56 Personal Reflections on Antizionism and Academia

38:37 Indigeneity and Cultural Identity

42:22 The Complexity of Genocide Narratives

48:13 Understanding Whiteness and Cultural Concerns

52:47 Historical Atrocities and Political Violence

55:45 The Organisation of Antizionist Movements

01:04:58 The Movement Against Antizionism
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

From algorithmic incentives to progressive posturing, this episode explores how anti-Semitism has become a feature—not a bug—of influencer culture. Zoe Booth speaks with Corey Walker, a Washington, D.C.-based reporter focusing on the Middle East and global terror groups, about audience capture, the anti-Western project of the modern Left, and why Israel represents values worth conserving.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices