Banking Transformed with Jim Marous

Melissa Stevens has a rule at Fifth Third: your employees are your brand.

The chief marketing officer of one of banking's strongest regional brands joins Jim Marous to explain how Fifth Third grows relationships from the inside out, by giving its people the data, the insight, and even the influencer status to become the bank's most trusted voices.

Stevens makes the case that customers never experience a bank as a marketing campaign. They experience it as the colleague who answers the question and solves the problem, and she has built her whole approach around that. That means letting employees post about the bank on social media without fully scripting what they say, because you can't script authenticity. It means arming bankers with insight, not just data, so a conversation is about the customer rather than the product. And it means watching for the quiet signals of a customer drifting away, like a direct deposit that suddenly splits in two, and reaching out before they're gone.

She's also candid about the tradeoffs. Fifth Third deliberately kept generative AI away from its customers, choosing accuracy over personality, after growing its Jeanie assistant from barely 20 percent accuracy in its early days to the low 90s. She talks through carrying 500,000 Comerica customers into a new brand without breaking their trust. And she grades herself an honest C-minus on the one thing she worries about most as the company grows.

For any bank or credit union trying to grow relationships in a crowded market, this is a clear look at what works and what most institutions get wrong about their own people.

Hosted by Jim Marous. Subscribe to Banking Transformed for new episodes multiple times each week.

We won the adoption argument. Every hand in the room. And the income statement didn't notice.

Four years ago, Jim Marous asked a room of bankers how many had used an AI tool in their work, and fewer than one in four hands went up. Last week he asked the same question and nearly every hand in the room went up, many of them belonging to bankers over 50. Adoption in the banking industry has moved faster than almost anything Jim has watched in his career. Over the same period, the share of organizations that can point to any impact of AI on their earnings has not changed.

This episode opens with a recurring pragmatic check-in on where banking actually is with AI, and it locates the gap elsewhere than in the technology. Banking has digitized the same way three times: paper became PDF, PDF moved behind a portal, and now the work inside the queue has been sped up. Every round improved the surface the work sits on. None of them touched the space between two departments. Mortgage lending shows the result on the income statement, where closings have come down roughly two weeks since 2021 while the cost to originate at a bank or credit union has stayed flat and pull-through has declined.

Retirement rollovers show the same failure landing on the customer, where an IRA application takes five minutes, and the transfer still runs on a paper check in the mail, during which about a third of job changers cash out instead.

The argument lands on ownership rather than tooling. Every step inside a department has an owner, a budget line, and a number. The space between two departments has none of the three, which is why three waves of digitalization kept landing on documents and never on the gaps. Jim closes with three moves: picking a process instead of a task, assigning one owner across the whole span, and measuring end-to-end.

About: Banking Transformed is hosted by Jim Marous, top five banking industry influencer and Co-Publisher of The Financial Brand. Banking Insights episodes deliver the most important strategic ideas in under ten minutes, for the executive who wants the takeaway without the deep dive. Subscribe to the Digital Banking Report at digitalbankingreport.com.

Most institutions aren't undifferentiated. Their differences are unwitnessed.

Cover the logo on the mobile app, the website and the branch sign, and most leadership teams cannot pick their own institution out of a lineup. Jim Marous opens this episode with that test, then turns it around: the problem is rarely that a bank or credit union has nothing worth choosing. The problem is that the advantage was built somewhere no customer will ever see or feel it.

The spine of the episode is an exercise Jim ran with a board recently. Everybody writes one sentence explaining why a customer banks with them, in the customer's words, and then the room crosses out anything that fails three tests. Distinctive, meaning the institution down the street could not write the same sentence. Valuable, meaning a customer has actually named it as the reason they chose or stayed, which most rooms cannot answer because nobody ever asked. And witnessed, meaning a customer can see, feel, measure or describe it through the channels they really use, and so can the prospect still deciding whether to start.

From the diagnosis come four moves: capture the customer's own words at the opening, at the anniversary, and on the way out; put a number in front of the customer once a year; publish real voices rather than institutional language; and approve nothing that cannot survive the same three tests. The episode closes on the harder question, which is what an institution should do when nothing survives at all.

About: Banking Transformed is hosted by Jim Marous, a top five banking industry influencer and Co-Publisher of The Financial Brand. Banking Insights episodes deliver the most important strategic ideas in under ten minutes, for the executive who wants the takeaway without the deep dive. Subscribe to the Digital Banking Report at digitalbankingreport.com.

Customer experience expert Jay Baer is stepping away from the keynote stage after 17 years and moving deeper into the world of tequila. He joins Jim Marous for a Banking Transformed conversation centered on five pours and five customer-experience questions for banks and credit unions.

Tequilas tasted, in order:

→ Nosotros Blanco

→ Lost Lore Joven

→ Arette Reposado

→ Wild Common Añejo

→ Cazcáñes #7 Extra Añejo

Each tequila opens a different discussion: first impressions, disconnected experiences across channels, the role of AI and automation, the difference between satisfaction and loyalty, and the advice Jay wants financial leaders to carry into the next decade.

Jay explains why connected customer experience is usually a culture and leadership challenge rather than a technology problem. He also argues that as AI tools become widely available, the human touch becomes more valuable, especially when something goes wrong.

His parting warning is direct: the more customers are treated like numbers, the more they will treat their financial institution as replaceable.

Jay Baer is the author of Talk Triggers and Hug Your Haters and co-founder of The Tequila Report.

Your NPS went up again last quarter. It still can't tell you which customers actually sent you somebody.

Gallup studied more than 24,000 banking customers. Run the standard formula and the score came out at 11. Change only how a 9 and a 7 get counted, and the same answers from the same people produce negative 14. Nobody was resurveyed. Nobody changed their mind.

Jim Marous makes the case that the industry's favorite metric records what customers say they might do, while the number that actually connects advocacy to growth records what they did. Only about 15% of customers ever produce a new customer, yet referred customers generate the vast majority of new customer profit, at a time when the cost of acquiring a customer has nearly doubled since 2019.

The episode covers why the score inflates on its own, the sampling problem nobody names, why the man who invented NPS built an accounting-based counterpart to it and why almost nobody adopted it, and five moves for building referral measurement as a permanent capability rather than another refer-a-friend campaign.

#Banking #CreditUnions #NPS #CustomerExperience #Referrals #FinancialServices