Seeing Like a State Study Guide
Seeing Like a State Study GuideShort Answer Quiz* According to Scott, what is the modern state's aspiration regarding social reality? The modern state aims to reduce the chaotic, ever-changing social reality to something resembling the administrative grid of its observations. This involves simplifying complex systems to make them more legible and controllable by the state.* Why does Scott suggest we should not assume local practice conforms with state theory? Local practices often develop organically and are influenced by various factors not accounted for in state-level planning. Informal systems of knowledge and practice persist that often contradict top-down state-driven initiatives, highlighting the disconnect between theory and lived reality.* How does Scott describe designed or planned social order? Designed social order is necessarily schematic, meaning it ignores the essential, informal features of a real, functioning society. Such planned order relies on simplified rules that are parasitic upon existing, often hidden, informal processes.* Explain the concept of 'work-to-rule' as it relates to Scott's arguments. A 'work-to-rule' strike demonstrates that everyday processes rely on informal practices and improvisations not captured by formal rules. By following rules meticulously, workers can halt or severely slow production, exposing the limitations of planned systems.* How does the text portray the role of language in relation to power? Language, despite being a joint creation of many speakers, is heavily influenced by linguists, educators, and the state. While language cannot be fully dictated, state-backed efforts can significantly shape its trajectory, though everyday spoken language often retains its own organic, diverse character.* What is "high modernism" according to the text? High modernism is a belief that the benefits of scientific and technical progress can be applied to all aspects of human activity, often through state intervention. It involves comprehensive prescriptions for a new society based on rational, simplified plans.* According to Scott, how do standard measures relate to commerce? Standard measures like weight and volume are crucial to commerce as they simplify long chains of transactions, particularly those between anonymous buyers and sellers. Standardisation makes trade more legible, which benefits large-scale exchange.* Why does the text use the analogy of "taxidermy" to describe certain social projects? The analogy of “taxidermy” illustrates how attempts to impose a rigid, planned order on society can stifle its vitality, dynamism, and ability to adapt. The outcome is not a living system, but a lifeless replica.* What does Scott mean by the term “legibility” in the context of statecraft? Legibility refers to the extent to which a society can be easily understood, observed, counted, and assessed by the state. States strive to make populations and their territories more legible to enhance control and administration, through standardisation and simplification.* What is the connection between high modernism and a weakened civil society, according to the text? High modernism finds fertile ground for implementation when a civil society lacks the power to resist state-led projects, allowing the state to impose top-down plans on the social terrain. A weak civil society cannot challenge these plans, contributing to failures in social engineering.Quiz Answer Key* The modern state aims to reduce the chaotic, ever-changing social reality to something resembling the administrative grid of its observations. This involves simplifying complex systems to make them more legible and controllable by the state.* Local practices often develop organically and are influenced by various factors not accounted for in state-level planning. Informal systems of knowledge and practice persist that often contradict top-down state-driven initiatives, highlighting the disconnect between theory and lived reality.* Designed social order is necessarily schematic, meaning it ignores the essential, informal features of a real, functioning society. Such planned order relies on simplified rules that are parasitic upon existing, often hidden, informal processes.* A 'work-to-rule' strike demonstrates that everyday processes rely on informal practices and improvisations not captured by formal rules. By following rules meticulously, workers can halt or severely slow production, exposing the limitations of planned systems.* Language, despite being a joint creation of many speakers, is heavily influenced by linguists, educators, and the state. While language cannot be fully dictated, state-backed efforts can significantly shape its trajectory, though everyday spoken language often retains its own organic, diverse character.* High modernism is a belief that the benefits of scientific and technical progress can be applied to all aspects of human activity, often through state intervention. It involves comprehensive prescriptions for a new society based on rational, simplified plans.* Standard measures like weight and volume are crucial to commerce as they simplify long chains of transactions, particularly those between anonymous buyers and sellers. Standardisation makes trade more legible, which benefits large-scale exchange.* The analogy of “taxidermy” illustrates how attempts to impose a rigid, planned order on society can stifle its vitality, dynamism, and ability to adapt. The outcome is not a living system, but a lifeless replica.* Legibility refers to the extent to which a society can be easily understood, observed, counted, and assessed by the state. States strive to make populations and their territories more legible to enhance control and administration, through standardisation and simplification.* High modernism finds fertile ground for implementation when a civil society lacks the power to resist state-led projects, allowing the state to impose top-down plans on the social terrain. A weak civil society cannot challenge these plans, contributing to failures in social engineering.Essay Questions* Drawing from the text, discuss how the concept of "legibility" facilitates state power, and provide examples of how states attempt to simplify social realities for easier management.* Analyse the relationship between high modernism, state power, and the failures of social engineering projects as described in the text. What are the key factors that contribute to these failures?* Using examples from the text, critically evaluate the notion of "scientific planning" in the context of social and urban development. What are the inherent limitations of such approaches?* Compare and contrast the perspectives of Jane Jacobs and Le Corbusier regarding urban planning, as presented in the text, and explore the underlying ideological differences between them.* Based on the readings, discuss the role of both high modernism and resistance to it in state-building efforts. What are the key factors that influence outcomes and which are most significant for success?Glossary of Key Terms* High Modernism: A belief in the transformative power of scientific and technical progress applied to all areas of life, often through state intervention and planning. It often seeks to impose a rational, simplified order on society.* Legibility: The capacity of the state to understand, observe, count, and manage its population and territory through simplified and standardised information.* State Simplification: The process by which states reduce complex social realities into simplified, manageable categories for administrative purposes, often resulting in the loss of valuable information and context.* Work-to-Rule: A form of protest in which employees strictly adhere to all formal rules and regulations, thus demonstrating that informal practices are essential for smooth functioning and exposing the limitations of formalised systems.* Social Taxidermy: A metaphor for the process by which attempts to impose a fixed, planned order on society stifle its vitality, dynamism, and ability to adapt, resulting in a lifeless, static replica of the intended social form.* Internal Colonization: The process by which a state applies its administrative techniques within its own borders, often with similar effects on local populations and customs as external colonial projects.* Utopian Vision: An idealised, often unrealistic vision of a future society based on principles of order and progress, which can become dangerous if implemented with authoritarian power.* Informal Practices: The unwritten rules, customs, and improvisations that govern everyday life and work, often existing outside the purview of formal, state-sanctioned systems.* Administrative Grid: The simplified, standardised framework through which the state observes and manages its population and territory, reducing complexity to facilitate control.* Technocracy: A system of governance in which decision-making is based on scientific and technical expertise, often leading to the exclusion of other perspectives and values. This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit depositologico.substack.com